Auction vs Private Sale in Victoria: What Buyers Need to Know | Property Home Base
Buyer guide

Auction vs Private Sale: What Buyers Need to Know

The two ways to buy a home work very differently. Knowing which one you face sets the timing, the preparation and the risk.

By Property Home Base · 6 minute read

THE SHORT ANSWER

In a private sale you negotiate a price with the seller and usually have a cooling-off period. At auction you bid in public and the sale is unconditional, with no cooling-off period and no finance clause, so finance, contract review and inspections must be finished before you bid.

PART 1

How Does a Private Sale Work?

Private sales are the most common way to buy. There is usually an asking price or an advertised price range, and you negotiate your offer with the selling agent, who works for the vendor.

There is a lot of variation in how private sales are run. Some agents ask for a best and final offer, where every buyer submits their top price without seeing the others. Others run a long back and forth until a price is agreed. Some will contact all interested buyers once an acceptable offer arrives. Ask the agent how this campaign will be run, who the offers go to and how competing offers will be handled.

What You Can Include in a Private Sale Offer

  • ✓The price and the deposit, and when the deposit is paid
  • ✓Conditions, such as subject to finance, subject to building and pest, or subject to a contract review
  • ✓The settlement date, which can matter to the vendor as much as the price
  • ✓An expiry time, so your offer does not sit open while the agent canvasses other buyers

Private sales usually come with a cooling-off period once the contract is signed. Read how cooling-off, deposits and finance conditions work.

PART 2

How Does an Auction Work?

At auction you bid in public against other buyers. When the auctioneer says sold, the contract is binding. There is no cooling-off period, no finance clause and no right to change your mind. If you cannot settle, you can lose your deposit and may be liable for further costs.

The Sequence on the Day

  1. 1Register to bid and show identification before the auction starts
  2. 2The auctioneer reads the terms and conditions and the vendor bid rules
  3. 3Bidding opens, and the auctioneer calls the property on the market once the reserve is reached
  4. 4The highest bidder wins if the property sells, signs the contract and pays the deposit, which is usually 10% (see the note below)
  5. 5If the reserve is not reached the property is passed in, and the highest bidder is usually given first opportunity to negotiate

In Victoria the vendor’s reserve price is published at least 7 days before the auction, so you can compare it with your research well before the day. See the reserve price rules.

For the full preparation list, see 5 Things To Do Before Buying At Auction.

PART 3

Side by Side

Auction compared with private sale
Private SaleAuction
How the price is setNegotiated from an asking price or rangeCompetitive bidding in public
Cooling-off periodUsually: 3 business days in Victoria, 2 in South AustraliaNone
ConditionsCan include finance, building and pest or contract reviewNone. The sale is unconditional
DepositPaid when you sign the contractUsually 10%, paid immediately if you win. Tell the agent before the auction if you will pay less
PreparationSome checks can be conditions of the offerEverything must be finished before the day
TimingFlexible, set by the negotiationFixed on the auction date
If you cannot settleDepends on the contractYou may lose your deposit
PART 4

Which Suits You?

Neither method is better in every case. The right approach depends on how prepared you are, how competitive the property is and how you handle pressure.

A Private Sale May Suit You If

  • ✓You want conditions such as finance or a building inspection
  • ✓You prefer to negotiate rather than bid in public
  • ✓You need time to arrange your finance or sell another property

An Auction May Suit You If

  • ✓Your finance, due diligence and limit are all locked in before the day
  • ✓You are comfortable being decisive under pressure
  • ✓You want a clear, transparent process where every buyer competes in the open
If you are unsure

Ask the selling agent how the property will be sold and when offers close. Then work back from that date for finance, the Section 32 and your inspections.

PART 5

Can You Buy Before the Auction?

Even when a property is advertised for auction, you can usually make an offer before auction day. A written offer on a Contract of Sale must be put to the vendor. If the vendor accepts, the property can be sold privately and the auction cancelled. Auction rules can apply in the days either side of an auction, so understand exactly which rules cover your offer before you sign anything.

Because this involves a binding contract, it is worth having a licensed Buyer’s Agent or a conveyancer review the offer first. See how a Buyer’s Agent can help.

PART 6

What Are the Common Mistakes?

  • ✓Treating an auction like a private sale and leaving finance or inspections until after the hammer falls
  • ✓Setting no limit, then bidding on emotion
  • ✓Assuming a deposit bond or finance condition will be accepted at auction
  • ✓Not checking whether the property is going to auction or private sale until the last week
  • ✓Ignoring the Section 32 and contract special conditions

Common Questions

Which is better for buyers, auction or private sale?

Neither is better in every case. Private sales give you a cooling-off period, conditions and room to negotiate. Auctions are faster and unconditional, so you need to be fully prepared before you bid.

Do I lose my deposit if I cannot settle after an auction?

Yes, you may. Auction sales are unconditional, so if you cannot settle you can lose your deposit and may be liable for further costs. Finish finance and due diligence before bidding.

Can I put an offer in before the auction?

Yes. A formal written offer on a Contract of Sale must be put to the vendor. If it is accepted, the property can be sold privately and the auction cancelled.

Can a Buyer’s Agent bid for me?

Yes. Our Consult, Bid & Negotiate service covers one property you have found, including bidding at auction, for $2,200 including GST.

Related

5 Things To Do Before Buying At AuctionFinance, research, due diligence and bidding.Deposits, Finance and Cooling-OffHow the contract mechanics work.Reserve Price Disclosure RulesWhat changed for Victorian auctions.Due DiligenceThe checks to complete before you commit.Buyers vs Sellers MarketHow market conditions change your approach.Case Study: Passed In At AuctionHow preparation and negotiation saved $50,000 after a passed-in auction.